Butler Manor

Learn About Butler Manor

Butler Manor is more than just a neighborhood; it is a piece of Staten Island’s maritime history. Originally the sprawling estate of 19th-century maritime magnate Elmer Butler, this pocket of the South Shore has evolved into one of the island’s most prestigious residential enclaves.Today, it is defined by its architectural diversity—from stately Center Hall Colonials to high-end new construction in the "Estates at Butler Manor." Residents choose this area for its quiet, winding streets and the sense of privacy that is increasingly rare in New York City. It is a community where the past is preserved in the grand stone gates and the future is built with modern luxury.

✦ Why I Love Butler Manor ✦

What I love most about Butler Manor is the way it feels tucked away from the rest of the world. Because it is bordered by the South Shore Bluebelt and the protected lands of Mount Loretto Unique Area, the neighborhood enjoys a permanent "privacy buffer."

The Coastal Views: There is nothing like a morning walk to the 75-foot bluffs—the highest ocean-facing cliffs in New York State—to see the Verrazzano and Sandy Hook on the horizon. The Wildlife: It’s a birdwatcher’s paradise. It’s not uncommon to spot an Osprey or a Great Egret (a nod to your blog series!) soaring over the Butler Manor Woods. The Tranquility: Even though you are minutes from the city's pulse, the only sound you often hear here is the wind through the trees or the waves hitting the shore at Prince's Bay.