The Staten Island real estate market remained active in May 2026, with steady buyer demand, strong sale-to-list results, and continued inventory movement across residential and multi-family homes.

According to the latest MLS data, 231 homes sold in May, with a median sold price of $750,000. Homes sold at an average of 97.46% of their list price, showing that well-positioned homes are still achieving strong results.

Buyer Demand Remained Steady

May closed with 231 homes sold, showing continued activity across Staten Island. While sales volume adjusted from April, buyers remained active, especially for homes that were priced correctly and marketed well.

Buyers are still making moves, but they are also taking more time to compare available options and evaluate value.

Prices Held Strong

The median sold price reached $750,000, slightly above April’s median sold price of $749,000. This shows that Staten Island home values remained resilient heading into the summer market.

Homes also sold at 97.46% of list price, reinforcing that sellers can still achieve strong results when pricing, presentation, and marketing are aligned.

Inventory Remained Active

May brought 487 new listings to the market, with 961 current active listings reported by the end of the month. Buyers continue to have more choices than earlier in the year, but strong demand is still supporting home values.

For sellers, this means standing out matters. A strong first impression, accurate pricing, and professional marketing strategy remain key.

What This Means for Sellers

Sellers are still in a strong position, but the market is becoming more selective. Homes that are properly prepared and priced are still getting attention, while homes that miss the mark may sit longer.

In this market, the first impression matters. Pricing, photography, staging, marketing, and negotiation strategy can all impact your final result.

What This Means for Buyers

Buyers have more options than they did earlier in the year, but desirable homes are still attracting attention. If a home is priced well and checks the right boxes, buyers should be prepared to move confidently.

The right strategy can help buyers understand value, compare opportunities, and make stronger decisions in a competitive but more balanced market.

Thinking About Selling?

If you are considering selling this summer, understanding your home’s position in the current market is important. Inventory has expanded, but well-prepared homes are still attracting attention and strong offers.

A personalized valuation can help you understand your home’s current market position and decide whether now is the right time to make a move.